
# End-to-End Test Report: Medklinix System

## 1. Summary
**Date:** 2026-02-07
**Tester:** QA Automation Agent
**Verdict:** **NOT PRODUCTION READY**

The application is in an early development stage. While the basic infrastructure (Next.js + Express + MongoDB) is running, critical user flows including **Registration** and **Patient Management** are functionally broken. The payment flow shows signs of integration but verification was limited due to account state.

## 2. Test Environment
- **OS:** Linux (Ubuntu)
- **Browser:** Chromium (Headless)
- **Backend:** Node.js/Express
- **Database:** MongoDB
- **Frontend:** Next.js 16

## 3. Tested Flows

| Flow | Status | Notes |
|------|--------|-------|
| **Registration** | 🔴 **FAILED** | Registration form is missing a `password` field. Users cannot log in after registering. |
| **Login** | 🟢 **PASSED** | Validated using a manually seeded QA account (`qa@clinic.com`). |
| **Dashboard Access** | 🟢 **PASSED** | Dashboard loads correctly after login. |
| **Add Patient** | 🔴 **FAILED** | Submitting the form returns `400 Bad Request`. Backend logic for creating a patient user + record is missing. |
| **View Patients** | 🟡 **BLOCKED** | Cannot verify patient list as creation fails. |
| **Subscription (UI)** | 🟡 **PARTIAL** | Pricing page loads. "Subscribe" button redirects to Stripe Checkout (verified redirection). |
| **Book Appointment** | 🟡 **BLOCKED** | Cannot book appointment without a valid patient. |

## 4. Issues Found

### 🚨 Critical / Blocker

| ID | Issue | Severity | Description | Recommendation |
|----|-------|----------|-------------|----------------|
| **BUG-001** | **Registration Missing Password** | **Blocker** | The `/register` page form accepts Name/Email but has **no Password field**. The backend generates a random password but does not display it, and email delivery was not verified. User is redirected to Login but cannot authenticate. | Add a `password` field to the Registration form and update the backend `register` controller to accept it. |
| **BUG-002** | **"Add Patient" Fails (API)** | **Critical** | The "Add Patient" form submits name/email data to `/api/patients`, but the Backend `PatientController` expects a `userId` (failed validation). The system attempts to save `firstName` on a Schema that doesn't have it. | Update `PatientController.ts` to perform a robust creation flow: Check if User exists -> Create User (if needed) -> Create Patient record linked to User. |

### ⚠️ Major

| ID | Issue | Severity | Description | Recommendation |
|----|-------|----------|-------------|----------------|
| **BUG-003** | **Missing Assets** | Major | Several images (e.g., `logo-digital.png`) fail to load (404/400 errors), making the app look broken. | Audit `public/` folder and update image paths in components. |
| **BUG-004** | **Broken Navigation** | Major | Direct URLs like `/plans` and `/subscription` return 404 pages. | Implement these pages or redirect them to the correct section on the Dashboard/Landing page. |
| **BUG-005** | **Localization Inconsistency** | Major | The UI mixes Spanish ("Iniciar Sesión") and English ("Add Patient"), creating a confusing user experience. | Standardize on one language or implement a proper i18n switcher. |

### ℹ️ Minor

| ID | Issue | Severity | Description | Recommendation |
|----|-------|----------|-------------|----------------|
| **UI-001** | **Hydration Errors** | Minor | Console logs show React hydration mismatches, likely due to invalid HTML nesting or date mismatches between server/client. | Fix HTML structure and ensure consistent date formatting. |

## 5. Technical Recommendations

### Immediate Fixes (Next Sprint)
1.  **Fix Registration**: Edit `client/app/(auth)/register/page.tsx` to include a password input. Updating `server/src/controllers/AuthController.ts` to respect the provided password.
2.  **Fix Patient Creation**: Refactor `PatientController.createPatient` to:
    ```typescript
    // Pseudo-code
    const user = await UserService.create({ email, password: tempPassword, ... });
    const patient = await PatientService.create({ userId: user._id, ... });
    ```
3.  **Seed Data**: Create a robust seed script that includes Patients and Appointments so testing isn't blocked by creation bugs.

## 6. Final Verdict
The product is **Pre-Alpha**. It requires immediate engineering attention on the Auth and Patient modules before any user onboarding can occur.
